@tylerblack32 @f_hieronymus @markhoro Psychotherapy studies are pretty impossible to judge. The performance biases are huge, beyond blinding. It’s almost impossible to control for “dose” and when you do it often makes the effect go away. Even when you don’
RT @psychunseen: 2/2 also, in this recent study, PE was not any more effective than SSRI w/ 15 minutes of non-trauma focused psychoeducati…
RT @psychunseen: 1/2 Cognitive Processing (CPT) & Prolonged Exposure (PE) are efficacious for combat-related #PTSD in #veterans. But no…
RT @psychunseen: 2/2 also, in this recent study, PE was not any more effective than SSRI w/ 15 minutes of non-trauma focused psychoeducati…
RT @psychunseen: 1/2 Cognitive Processing (CPT) & Prolonged Exposure (PE) are efficacious for combat-related #PTSD in #veterans. But no…
2/2 also, in this recent study, PE was not any more effective than SSRI w/ 15 minutes of non-trauma focused psychoeducation/active listening (and combo of both not more effective) https://t.co/AZ2rd19ocA https://t.co/PvMD62w5O4
Ouch. How about those odds...
The dangers of prolonged exposure in a succinct tweet summarizing a comprehensive study. I opt out of PE for most clients, instead choosing to use techniques like the ACT Matrix by @KevinPolk and others to re-organize traumatic experiences. Effective and m
RT @clinpsychbook: Something clinicians know but many researchers don’t: People drop out of therapy when the treatment you’re providing is…
And that 1-in-3 chance of doing better beats out psychodynamic and pretty much every other type of treatment orientation.
RT @clinpsychbook: Something clinicians know but many researchers don’t: People drop out of therapy when the treatment you’re providing is…
It’s difficult to use the opinions of POST 9/11 Veterans when it comes to PTSD treatment success First the diagnosis is probabaly wrong Second Post 9/11 Vetetans receive far more V.A. disablity & Caregiver pay than they could ever earn at work We p
RT @clinpsychbook: Something clinicians know but many researchers don’t: People drop out of therapy when the treatment you’re providing is…
RT @clinpsychbook: Something clinicians know but many researchers don’t: People drop out of therapy when the treatment you’re providing is…
RT @clinpsychbook: Something clinicians know but many researchers don’t: People drop out of therapy when the treatment you’re providing is…
RT @clinpsychbook: Based on this RCT of Prolonged Exposure with veterans, the informed consent for this procedure should say, “There’s a 50…
RT @clinpsychbook: Something clinicians know but many researchers don’t: People drop out of therapy when the treatment you’re providing is…
Something clinicians know but many researchers don’t: People drop out of therapy when the treatment you’re providing is not helping them. @JonathanShedler @AllenFrancesMD
I can’t stand PE and it makes me sick how much my school pushes this crap therapy for #trauma. If you’re going to be #evidencebased you should share ALL the evidence, not just what’s convenient for you.
RT @clinpsychbook: Based on this RCT of Prolonged Exposure with veterans, the informed consent for this procedure should say, “There’s a 50…
RT @clinpsychbook: Based on this RCT of Prolonged Exposure with veterans, the informed consent for this procedure should say, “There’s a 50…
Based on this RCT of Prolonged Exposure with veterans, the informed consent for this procedure should say, “There’s a 50% chance you won’t complete the treatment, but if you do, there’s about a 1-in-3 chance you’ll have a 50% reduction in symptoms.” https:
For patients who completed treatment, the rates of Remission (no longer meets PTSD diagnosis) and Response (50% reduction in symptom severity) at 24 weeks: Sertraline = 39.4, 40.8 PE + placebo = 20.9, 26.9 PE + sertraline = 37.7, 37.7
“The dropout rate...was 26.8% for the sertraline plus enhanced medication management group, 47.8% for the prolonged exposure therapy plus placebo group, and 40.6% for the prolonged exposure therapy plus sertraline group.” https://t.co/EoiJwdcS2D
@Michael46830937 for you. Treating mental health is complex. I have also seen the downside of medications wrongly prescribed, but thankful for those that help people. Sadly, talk therapy is not rewarded enough in my humble opinion. I see treatment as holis
RT @PeterDKramer: For #PTSD, prolonged exposure therapy plus #SSRI offers no extra benefit over either treatment (med or #psychotherapy) al…
For #PTSD, prolonged exposure therapy plus #SSRI offers no extra benefit over either treatment (med or #psychotherapy) alone. Yet another instance in which med & psychotherapy are not additive. (Similar result can occur also in Rx of #depression or #AD
@royperlis @RudolfUher Really? Every psychotherapy trial works this way. And there’s this: https://t.co/SrBjgQcwGk
RT @mpwpaulus: No evidence that combinations of treatment approaches are better in PTSD https://t.co/Di1zpAemhB
VA is all-in with trauma-focused therapies, but it unclear that they are necessary or feasible. Less intensive, less intrusive therapies may be as good. https://t.co/saei2KgTsa https://t.co/4EFz3mMkSx
RT @JAMAPsych: This is #RCT explores impact of medications, therapy, and combination treatment in treating combat veterans with #PTSD https…
RT @CarmenMcLeanPhD: Prolonged Exposure + pill placebo = Sertraline + medication management in combat #veterans with #PTSD https://t.co/O4B…
RT @CarmenMcLeanPhD: Prolonged Exposure + pill placebo = Sertraline + medication management in combat #veterans with #PTSD https://t.co/O4B…
RT @CarmenMcLeanPhD: Prolonged Exposure + pill placebo = Sertraline + medication management in combat #veterans with #PTSD https://t.co/O4B…
RT @JAMAPsych: This is #RCT explores impact of medications, therapy, and combination treatment in treating combat veterans with #PTSD https…
RT @CarmenMcLeanPhD: Prolonged Exposure + pill placebo = Sertraline + medication management in combat #veterans with #PTSD https://t.co/O4B…
RT @CarmenMcLeanPhD: Prolonged Exposure + pill placebo = Sertraline + medication management in combat #veterans with #PTSD https://t.co/O4B…
RT @CarmenMcLeanPhD: Prolonged Exposure + pill placebo = Sertraline + medication management in combat #veterans with #PTSD https://t.co/O4B…
RT @JAMAPsych: This is #RCT explores impact of medications, therapy, and combination treatment in treating combat veterans with #PTSD https…
RT @mpwpaulus: No evidence that combinations of treatment approaches are better in PTSD https://t.co/Di1zpAemhB
RT @JAMAPsych: This is #RCT explores impact of medications, therapy, and combination treatment in treating combat veterans with #PTSD https…
RT @JAMAPsych: This is #RCT explores impact of medications, therapy, and combination treatment in treating combat veterans with #PTSD https…
No evidence that combinations of treatment approaches are better in PTSD
RT @JAMAPsych: This is #RCT explores impact of medications, therapy, and combination treatment in treating combat veterans with #PTSD https…
This is #RCT explores impact of medications, therapy, and combination treatment in treating combat veterans with #PTSD https://t.co/jtqGRLuZKG https://t.co/41NUC9mvGh
النتيجة مقنعةوإن كانت غير متوافقة مع زخم الثقيف المحلي. Efficacy of Prol Exposure Therapy, Sertraline , and Their Combination Among Combat Veterans With Posttraumatic Stress Dis: A Randomized Clinical Trial. | Psychiatry | JAMA Psychiatry | JAMA Network h
RT @Rebecca_Sripada: Prolonged Exposure Therapy, Sertraline, and Their Combination Among Combat Veterans With PTSD https://t.co/sfbbBzknlv.…
No difference in change in PTSD symptoms or symptom severity at 24 weeks was found between sertraline plus enhanced medication management, prolonged exposure therapy plus placebo, and prolonged exposure therapy plus sertraline https://t.co/Gt63BwOv1u
RT @HengartnerMP: No difference between 1) Sertraline + medication management 2) exposure therapy + sertraline and 3) exposure therapy + pl…
RT @Rebecca_Sripada: Prolonged Exposure Therapy, Sertraline, and Their Combination Among Combat Veterans With PTSD https://t.co/sfbbBzknlv.…
Studies show therapy in combination w/ medication can produce greater mental health benefits than antidepressants alone #TuesdayThoughts https://t.co/nEn86AwGP7
RT @Rebecca_Sripada: Prolonged Exposure Therapy, Sertraline, and Their Combination Among Combat Veterans With PTSD https://t.co/sfbbBzknlv.…
24週間の治療終了後におけるPTSDの症状や重篤度は、セルトラリン+増強投薬管理、長期暴露療法+プラセボ、長期暴露療法+セルトラリンで違うとはいえない。Efficacy of Prolonged Exposure Therapy, Sertraline Hydrochloride, and Their Combination Among Combat… https://t.co/K6IQJoDvSm
No difference in change in PTSD symptoms or symptom severity at 24 weeks was found between sertraline plus enhanced medication management, prolonged exposure therapy plus placebo, and prolonged exposure therapy plus sertraline https://t.co/VQ6VDyEsl3
Prolonged Exposure Therapy, Sertraline, and Their Combination Among Combat Veterans With PTSD https://t.co/2Jl3IVcDE1
RT @HengartnerMP: No difference between 1) Sertraline + medication management 2) exposure therapy + sertraline and 3) exposure therapy + pl…
Prolonged Exposure Therapy, Sertraline, and Their Combination Among Combat Veterans With PTSD https://t.co/sfbbBzknlv. All three treatment arms resulted in large symptom reductions. @JAMAPsych https://t.co/Tph2KJ9PpA
RT @HengartnerMP: No difference between 1) Sertraline + medication management 2) exposure therapy + sertraline and 3) exposure therapy + pl…
RT @HengartnerMP: No difference between 1) Sertraline + medication management 2) exposure therapy + sertraline and 3) exposure therapy + pl…
RT @CoyneoftheRealm: Efficacy of Prolonged Exposure Therapy, Sertraline Hydrochloride, and Their Combination Among Combat Veterans With #Po…
@HengartnerMP A virtual dime for your thoughts on the results of this trial. Is an average change of approximately 30-points in all conditions a positive result? Or is the non-significant difference between the conditions a disappointing result? cc. @Coyne
No parecen haber diferencias entre psicoterapia, medicación o la combinación en el tratamiento del estrés postraumático a 6 meses. https://t.co/IB9O5fTKXt https://t.co/6vytKoBEhI
Efficacy of Prolonged Exposure Therapy, Sertraline Hydrochloride, and Their Combination Among Combat Veterans With #Posttraumatic Stress Disorder A Randomized Clinical Trial, https://t.co/W6i8nzBo9X 2/2
No difference in change in PTSD symptoms between sertraline plus enhanced medication management, prolonged exposure therapy (PE) plus placebo, and PE plus sertraline https://t.co/bIv7D8u0hd Not quite sure whether we should deem this result as uplifting or
RT @HengartnerMP: No difference between 1) Sertraline + medication management 2) exposure therapy + sertraline and 3) exposure therapy + pl…
RT @HengartnerMP: No difference between 1) Sertraline + medication management 2) exposure therapy + sertraline and 3) exposure therapy + pl…
RT @HengartnerMP: No difference between 1) Sertraline + medication management 2) exposure therapy + sertraline and 3) exposure therapy + pl…
No difference between 1) Sertraline + medication management 2) exposure therapy + sertraline and 3) exposure therapy + placebo pill in the treatment of PTSD. https://t.co/7WCXWzObFP
Prolonged Exposure Therapy, Sertraline, and Their Combination Among Combat Veterans With PTSD https://t.co/NCWyy0Elus