RT @digiphile: In 1918, after the flu came roaring back in the winter, city & state officials enforced public health measures over the loud…
RT @digiphile: In 1918, after the flu came roaring back in the winter, city & state officials enforced public health measures over the loud…
RT @digiphile: In 2022, after COVID-19 came roaring back in the winter, local officials enforced public health measures, from masks to test…
RT @digiphile: In 1918, after the flu came roaring back in the winter, city & state officials enforced public health measures over the loud…
RT @digiphile: In 1918, after the flu came roaring back in the winter, city & state officials enforced public health measures over the loud…
@JuliaRaifman If I read the situation right, we face a dire winter. 2022 will be like 1918, where local officials are forced to try to implement mandatory masking & quarantines due to overloaded hospital systems, & church leaders & armed, defia
RT @digiphile: In 2022, after COVID-19 came roaring back in the winter, local officials enforced public health measures, from masks to test…
In 2022, after COVID-19 came roaring back in the winter, local officials enforced public health measures, from masks to testing to vaccines, over the protests of businesses & churches. Where they didn't, people died, sickened by mistrust & misinfo
RT @troydee: @FraiseAdam The JAMA analysis of data from 1918 is an interesting read on how NPI like masking and lockdowns controlled (or di…
@FraiseAdam The JAMA analysis of data from 1918 is an interesting read on how NPI like masking and lockdowns controlled (or didn’t) the spread of Spanish flu. https://t.co/DX6yz76mWc
RT @christianperez: entre un 30-50%. La ciudad de NY fue un ejemplo, que se caracterizó por reaccionar antes a la crisis con horarios comer…
entre un 30-50%. La ciudad de NY fue un ejemplo, que se caracterizó por reaccionar antes a la crisis con horarios comerciales escalonados y cuarentenas obligatorias. Fue esta ciudad la que experimentaría la tasa de mortalidad más baja de la costa oeste htt
https://t.co/Wlb8Zjt8L1 "...findings demonstrate a strong association between early, sustained, and layered application of nonpharmaceutical interventions..." that linked a two-amino acid change to the end of the pandemic. God help you if you got injected
RT @JonSchw73589513: @MattEdom @guffynicola @ClarkeMicah 1/ Hitchens is clearly not sincere in asking how we know that NPIs save lives. The…
@MattEdom @guffynicola @ClarkeMicah 1/ Hitchens is clearly not sincere in asking how we know that NPIs save lives. The literature on this subject is vast. It has been studied since the 1918/19 influenza pandemic. Here’s a short paper in the topic. https://
RT @digiphile: In 1918, after the flu came roaring back in the winter, city & state officials enforced public health measures over the loud…
RT @digiphile: In 1918, after the flu came roaring back in the winter, city & state officials enforced public health measures over the loud…
@SpiralChris Responding to a new pandemic by definition requires novel combinations chosen from a range of possible non-pharmaceutical interventions to mitigate the rapidly emerging risk. See eg. Table 3 (published 2007) https://t.co/8A4lWAUzaU
@DrEliDavid @yaacovbaruch @SunetraGupta supporting mask use clearly _do_ exist & have been widely reported in the scientific literature. You can find studies of mask use with identical conclusions carried out well before this pandemic as well. E.g.
@JBradshaw01 @SGaibrie Trying to ascertain how NPIs worked in 1918-1919 after the fact (study from 2997): https://t.co/2pI2LsQrfx
@xMatPKx @WarmingIs @MumsDev @MarceloM11SEP @rafinhagomes00 @GFiuza_Oficial https://t.co/UMipKcVB5h "As cidades que implementaram intervenções não farmacêuticas anteriormente tiveram maiores atrasos em atingir o pico de mortalidade, menores taxas de mortal
RT @digiphile: Vaccination, masking, physical distancing, testing, ventilating & shifting events outside make social gatherings safer & low…
RT @digiphile: Vaccination, masking, physical distancing, testing, ventilating & shifting events outside make social gatherings safer & low…
Vaccination, masking, physical distancing, testing, ventilating & shifting events outside make social gatherings safer & lower risk in a pandemic. Not requiring vaccination & masks at an indoor camp or conference is a recipe for an outbreak: h
RT @AtomsksSanakan: PapersOfTheDay @epsilon3141: https://t.co/aKGsR3bXpL "Nonpharmaceutical interventions implemented by US cities [...]"…
RT @digiphile: Pediatric hospitalizations are growing: https://t.co/HPvkuQKUFK As cases soar in Texas & schools open, @GovAbbott’s stance…
The Edtech is booming nowadays. The possibility of Edtech is great. Here are the apps of Edtech. https://t.co/03k3LQ4GWU https://t.co/4WO6a9M2at https://t.co/UwxxT6uKEs With these apps, you can master mathematics and languages quickly.
RT @digiphile: Pediatric hospitalizations are growing: https://t.co/HPvkuQKUFK As cases soar in Texas & schools open, @GovAbbott’s stance…
RT @digiphile: Pediatric hospitalizations are growing: https://t.co/HPvkuQKUFK As cases soar in Texas & schools open, @GovAbbott’s stance…
RT @digiphile: Pediatric hospitalizations are growing: https://t.co/HPvkuQKUFK As cases soar in Texas & schools open, @GovAbbott’s stance…
Pediatric hospitalizations are growing: https://t.co/HPvkuQKUFK As cases soar in Texas & schools open, @GovAbbott’s stance on masks will prove deadly: https://t.co/LqgKkTRiaH History, repeating itself: https://t.co/vVBHtYZgAU https://t.co/BtK8w3w3A
@msnorthcott Note US in Spanish flu. Short duration closures and selective. https://t.co/yWlsou1KBU
Nonpharmaceutical Interventions Implemented by US Cities During the 1918-1919 Influenza Pandemic https://t.co/v3zqYdAf6M @JAMA_current @JAMANetwork
@UlyssesRufus @TAH_Sci @WesPegden @drvictoriafox @BallouxFrancois Here are the academic papers on the 1918 LD in the US. They give a fuller picture. But I think you are right, LD more severe this time https://t.co/sxJcJnktAC https://t.co/DWQgJcaNJg
@maewald Mit der Spanischen Grippe konnte es schon der Wildtyp aufnehmen. Zumindest in New York gab es vergleichbar viele Tote (Einwohner-Adjustiert zu 1918) https://t.co/noWdDxDcTY
RT @digiphile: In 1918, after the flu came roaring back in the winter, city & state officials enforced public health measures over the loud…
The @WashingtonPost analyzed @cdcgov data & found coronavirus cases dropping in states where most people have been immunized, & hospitalizations are rising where vaccination rates are low: https://t.co/D39GyVYkOv In 2021, our laboratories of democr
@andistue @GabrielaThurg lö wuala, die studie. https://t.co/KNEb1Dzv38
@BMFiore2 not a particularly constructive reply. heres evidence from 1918 https://t.co/rKZYVgqPfI.
@LegoLas44941816 @davies_will There were lockdowns in American cities in 1918. https://t.co/fiFeVY8due
@ljtcpa @charles_gaba Gentleman’s bet 🤝that the cities & states with mask mandates in 2020 & high vaccination rates in 2021 recover faster by 2022, parallel to the patterns of 1918-1920.
There are lots of interesting studies on NPIs, including a focus on the 1918 Pandemic. Here are two: https://t.co/7baMdWA10l and https://t.co/JVssUkfqnq. What strikes me about all of them are the caveats about timing, local conditions, compliance and enfor
@fjpinto1960 @DrEricDing That #SARSCoV2 has at least the same potential for causing death as the 1918 Spanish Flu pandemic can be easily seen from excess mortality data of hard hit places like NYC. And in 1918 there were zero ICUs availabe. OTOH 1918 victi
@JustinLessler Has been known already since the 1. coronavirus wave hit NYC last spring that #covid19 can be as deadly as the 1918 Spanish Flu virus. https://t.co/noWdDxDcTY
@nomadicparamed1 @InProportion2 Lockdowns work: https://t.co/zZI21cXSAg
We knew what to do in 1919...& 2020...then WHY DIE?
@ClaraJeffery @HiddenBrain Just going to drop this thread right here.
@florian_krammer @johnmbarry Also of interest, the JAMA study of the 1918 Pandemic.
@MarmaladeMax Re: "I'll restate" Re-stating your evidence-free denialist lies doesn't make them any less of a lie. https://t.co/Uy64yotkVX https://t.co/3rkYrn3XLD https://t.co/X7Eeq6P75I
@MarmaladeMax @indepdubnrth Re: "I repeat: EVERYWHERE you look, covid deaths do not exceed bad flu years." Your evidence-free claim is noted, as is your evasion of evidence that shows you're wrong. Don't worry: I don't expect better from you denialist de
@franciscome Gracias por leer. A continuación le comparto algunos de los textos usados: https://t.co/kyDNFOG2nk https://t.co/yJLKBOTyNp https://t.co/U0SRO1q8aZ https://t.co/ZujQcb6IvB https://t.co/Gz9xfFhFgl
@VhZvhorn @MightyMommy024 @RandPaul These findings demonstrate a strong association between early, sustained, and layered application of nonpharmaceutical interventions and mitigating the consequences of the 1918-1919 influenza pandemic in the United State
Nonpharmaceutical Interventions Implemented by US Cities During the 1918-1919 Influenza Pandemic https://t.co/drgoAvgrXU via @JAMA_current part of @JAMANetwork
RT @SafaMote: A larger second peak was observed in 1918–19 in St Louis & Denver during the Spanish Flu. Figure from Markel et al., 2007. “…
RT @digiphile: In 1918, after the flu came roaring back in the winter, city & state officials enforced public health measures over the loud…
RT @DasUlrike: #onderwijs #geschiedenis Pro-actief scholen sluiten (+ verbod samenscholing) in 1918/19 meest effectieve maatregel om piek b…
#onderwijs #geschiedenis Pro-actief scholen sluiten (+ verbod samenscholing) in 1918/19 meest effectieve maatregel om piek besmettingen/sterfgevallen te voorkomen. Nonpharmaceutical Interventions (..) US Cities during 1918-1919 Influenza Pandemic https://t
RT @Hiroshi_Tsuji: 経済活動学校再開のタイミング。再開したら何が起きるか?2007年掲載米JAMA誌の1918年スペイン風邪の際の米各都市対応と、その後の感染拡大状況が米国で話題になってます。死者がほぼ0人に近い状態になる前に解除した都市はより高い第2波を迎え…
RT @Hiroshi_Tsuji: 経済活動学校再開のタイミング。再開したら何が起きるか?2007年掲載米JAMA誌の1918年スペイン風邪の際の米各都市対応と、その後の感染拡大状況が米国で話題になってます。死者がほぼ0人に近い状態になる前に解除した都市はより高い第2波を迎え…
RT @Hiroshi_Tsuji: 経済活動学校再開のタイミング。再開したら何が起きるか?2007年掲載米JAMA誌の1918年スペイン風邪の際の米各都市対応と、その後の感染拡大状況が米国で話題になってます。死者がほぼ0人に近い状態になる前に解除した都市はより高い第2波を迎え…
@wldnsadb @CT_Bergstrom “IFR in that range for numerous times in past flu pandemics” this is not true. COVID 19 caused several times more excess mortality than any flu pandemic in the last 100 years The only pandemic comparable to COVID-19 was the 1918 Spa
@justin_hart And, what do you know, it worked then, too. https://t.co/iiXQxFOcuE
RT @AtomsksSanakan: PapersOfTheDay @epsilon3141: https://t.co/aKGsR3bXpL "Nonpharmaceutical interventions implemented by US cities [...]"…
The table above includes total deaths and excess deaths in an "unmitigated pandemic without interventions". Mitigation limited SARS-CoV-2 infections + COVID-19 deaths, despite SARS-CoV-2 being category 5 for case fatality ratio. https://t.co/Uy64yotkVX
RT @Hiroshi_Tsuji: 経済活動学校再開のタイミング。再開したら何が起きるか?2007年掲載米JAMA誌の1918年スペイン風邪の際の米各都市対応と、その後の感染拡大状況が米国で話題になってます。死者がほぼ0人に近い状態になる前に解除した都市はより高い第2波を迎え…
RT @Hiroshi_Tsuji: 経済活動学校再開のタイミング。再開したら何が起きるか?2007年掲載米JAMA誌の1918年スペイン風邪の際の米各都市対応と、その後の感染拡大状況が米国で話題になってます。死者がほぼ0人に近い状態になる前に解除した都市はより高い第2波を迎え…
RT @TallDavid: @CrossTamedHeart @GregAbbott_TX False. JAMA, Nonpharmaceutical Interventions Implemented by US Cities During the 1918-1919…
@CrossTamedHeart @JuliansRum #ResignAbbott JAMA, Nonpharmaceutical Interventions Implemented by US Cities During the 1918-1919 Influenza Pandemic, Aug. 8, 2007 https://t.co/uloG0W9Tqv
@CrossTamedHeart @GregAbbott_TX False. JAMA, Nonpharmaceutical Interventions Implemented by US Cities During the 1918-1919 Influenza Pandemic, Aug. 8, 2007 #ResignAbbott https://t.co/uloG0W9Tqv
RT @megasametaro: >後から批判するのはフェアではない 昨年10月、最善を尽くした安倍総理を貶めたいだけの「新型コロナ対応・民間臨時調査会」なる報告書が、終息もしてない、コロナ禍の全体像もはっきり見えてない時に、しかも「遡及的」で一方的な論評で出されたことには…
RT @mph_for_doctors: ちなみに記事の中で昨年2月の学校の休校についても触れられていますが、これは安倍前総理も国会で1918-9年のスペイン風邪を参考にしたと答弁しており、エビデンス的にも妥当だと思います。 小児の症例が少ないことから"過剰な対策"と後から批…
RT @mph_for_doctors: ちなみに記事の中で昨年2月の学校の休校についても触れられていますが、これは安倍前総理も国会で1918-9年のスペイン風邪を参考にしたと答弁しており、エビデンス的にも妥当だと思います。 小児の症例が少ないことから"過剰な対策"と後から批…
RT @megasametaro: >後から批判するのはフェアではない 昨年10月、最善を尽くした安倍総理を貶めたいだけの「新型コロナ対応・民間臨時調査会」なる報告書が、終息もしてない、コロナ禍の全体像もはっきり見えてない時に、しかも「遡及的」で一方的な論評で出されたことには…
RT @megasametaro: >後から批判するのはフェアではない 昨年10月、最善を尽くした安倍総理を貶めたいだけの「新型コロナ対応・民間臨時調査会」なる報告書が、終息もしてない、コロナ禍の全体像もはっきり見えてない時に、しかも「遡及的」で一方的な論評で出されたことには…
RT @digiphile: Anti-mask sentiment & protests were present a century ago, too: https://t.co/8xzZEDIESv Leaders who don’t learn from history…
RT @digiphile: Anti-mask sentiment & protests were present a century ago, too: https://t.co/8xzZEDIESv Leaders who don’t learn from history…
RT @mph_for_doctors: ちなみに記事の中で昨年2月の学校の休校についても触れられていますが、これは安倍前総理も国会で1918-9年のスペイン風邪を参考にしたと答弁しており、エビデンス的にも妥当だと思います。 小児の症例が少ないことから"過剰な対策"と後から批…
RT @megasametaro: >後から批判するのはフェアではない 昨年10月、最善を尽くした安倍総理を貶めたいだけの「新型コロナ対応・民間臨時調査会」なる報告書が、終息もしてない、コロナ禍の全体像もはっきり見えてない時に、しかも「遡及的」で一方的な論評で出されたことには…
RT @dtwyman: @sarahzhang @MollyJongFast Actually, people didn’t forget, they also did an examination of non pharmaceutical interventions in…
@sarahzhang @MollyJongFast Actually, people didn’t forget, they also did an examination of non pharmaceutical interventions in the last flu pandemic. But those who forget history are condemned to repeat it, etc... Great article though!
@greg_travis @ZachariaKing28 @danjcyr @Mollie_Whuppie @MLevitt_NP2013 Re: "It's a comparison" Zachy doesn't realize that he (not you) is pooling Spanish flu deaths across multiple years using excess death, compared to reported deaths for 1 year for COVID-
@danjcyr @ZachariaKing28 @greg_travis @Mollie_Whuppie @MLevitt_NP2013 Re: "1918 flu was never worse than sc2, to compare is fruitless as medicine had advanced so far since then." Again, it's like trying to get through to a brick wall. https://t.co/Uy64yo
I know this is a different situation, but we can still always look to history and science to help with problems of today “Nonpharmaceutical Interventions Implemented by US Cities During the 1918-1919 Influenza Pandemic” | Geriatrics | JAMA | JAMA Network
RT @solsilvanazb: Aprender del pasado: en 1918 Cuando comenzaron las escuelas y las reuniones sociales, a tornarse normales y sin control e…
Dieser Vergleich zwischen #Covid19 und der Spanischen Grippe ist augenöffnend: 100 Jahre medizinische Entwicklung und trotzdem verläuft Corona tödlicher.
@HeinerULTRAS @Helene12111 @DrChristianWin1 @m_grill @OlafGersemann @KirstenThommes @ElisaTset Welche email? Es dreht sich alles hier auf Twitter... Nocovid, ZeroCovid, Corona Maßnahmen, Austausch, usw.. hätte mir das jemand vor 1-2 Jahren mal gesagt.
@DrChristianWin1 Ich helfe Ihnen mal weiter. Ihr Namensvetter muss vermutlich dieses hier gelesen haben.
RT @megasametaro: >後から批判するのはフェアではない 昨年10月、最善を尽くした安倍総理を貶めたいだけの「新型コロナ対応・民間臨時調査会」なる報告書が、終息もしてない、コロナ禍の全体像もはっきり見えてない時に、しかも「遡及的」で一方的な論評で出されたことには…
@NasimaRazmyar Espanjantaudissa ne USA:n kaupungit pärjäsivät parhaiten, joissa toimenpiteet taudin tukahduttamiseksi tehtiin aikaisemmin (kuin myöhemmin). https://t.co/Wo5I2NPJdy
@OlegRoslak @zorinaq It is the other way round: #covid not is not remotely comparable to any normal flu season. The only pandemic comparable to #covid is 1918 Spanish Flu. Also consider 1918 had neither mechanical ventilation nor antibiotics (for 2ndary ba
RT @mph_for_doctors: ちなみに記事の中で昨年2月の学校の休校についても触れられていますが、これは安倍前総理も国会で1918-9年のスペイン風邪を参考にしたと答弁しており、エビデンス的にも妥当だと思います。 小児の症例が少ないことから"過剰な対策"と後から批…
RT @Hiroshi_Tsuji: 経済活動学校再開のタイミング。再開したら何が起きるか?2007年掲載米JAMA誌の1918年スペイン風邪の際の米各都市対応と、その後の感染拡大状況が米国で話題になってます。死者がほぼ0人に近い状態になる前に解除した都市はより高い第2波を迎え…
RT @mph_for_doctors: ちなみに記事の中で昨年2月の学校の休校についても触れられていますが、これは安倍前総理も国会で1918-9年のスペイン風邪を参考にしたと答弁しており、エビデンス的にも妥当だと思います。 小児の症例が少ないことから"過剰な対策"と後から批…
RT @mph_for_doctors: ちなみに記事の中で昨年2月の学校の休校についても触れられていますが、これは安倍前総理も国会で1918-9年のスペイン風邪を参考にしたと答弁しており、エビデンス的にも妥当だと思います。 小児の症例が少ないことから"過剰な対策"と後から批…
RT @mph_for_doctors: ちなみに記事の中で昨年2月の学校の休校についても触れられていますが、これは安倍前総理も国会で1918-9年のスペイン風邪を参考にしたと答弁しており、エビデンス的にも妥当だと思います。 小児の症例が少ないことから"過剰な対策"と後から批…
RT @Hiroshi_Tsuji: 経済活動学校再開のタイミング。再開したら何が起きるか?2007年掲載米JAMA誌の1918年スペイン風邪の際の米各都市対応と、その後の感染拡大状況が米国で話題になってます。死者がほぼ0人に近い状態になる前に解除した都市はより高い第2波を迎え…
RT @mph_for_doctors: ちなみに記事の中で昨年2月の学校の休校についても触れられていますが、これは安倍前総理も国会で1918-9年のスペイン風邪を参考にしたと答弁しており、エビデンス的にも妥当だと思います。 小児の症例が少ないことから"過剰な対策"と後から批…
RT @hichachu: https://t.co/onYPDj4iDK 解析対象となった43都市では、24週間の間に115,340人の肺炎・インフルエンザの過剰死亡(EDR、人口500人/10万人)があった。すべての都市で、3つの主要カテゴリーの非医薬品介入のうち少なくとも…